Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Forgive Me if I Vent a Little

I'm a little frustrated. Very frustrated. I need to vent about this but it is very complicated and I'm not sure that I will be able to explain it very clearly, especially with all of my frustration. But I'm going to give it a try.

The school system is introducing a new grading standard for first and second graders. (Jonathon is in the second grade) They told us that they were introducing this new standard a couple of weeks after school started but nothing really changed as far as the papers that were sent home. Meaning that the papers were still sent home with number grades such as 102, 79, 93. These grades were a way for us as parents to tell what our children were doing well at and what they were struggling with. We got our first report cards for the year last week. And they did not reflect these number grades at all. This is a copy of our new grading system.



Jonathon came home with a report card that simply had P's on it. No more numbers to let me know what his particular strengths and weaknesses are, just p's letting me know he is 'progressing'. And can I just say that if I am sending him to school every day he better darn well be 'progressing'.

I went up to the school the next day to complain about the report cards and how insufficient they were for giving me the information that I need to help my child succeed and the lady told me, ' It doesn't really matter if you complain because this will be going statewide next year.' To which I became very red in the face and suddenly felt very hot. I said, (very calmly might I add) that as long as my child was in the public school system I feel like I have every right to complain about whatever I felt neccessary and that she should not really tell people that their voices won't be heard. She said she would have the guidance councilor call me to explain the system to me.

The guidance councilor called to give me some much needed guidance. It sounds like every child brought home the same report card because they should all be 'progressing' toward 'mastery'. She explained that the teachers have a very specific criteria that they access the kids with and there is not a child that will have mastered everything in the beginning of the school year. We had a long talk and I still was not 'drinking her kool-aid' if you know what I mean but she said that I would remain informed.

Then this week I got a note home that said they would have a meeting about their new grading system and I immediately called Echo. Echo has been equally up in arms over this whole new system. So, she was just as excited for the opportunity to vent about the new system as I was.

And vent we did. We got to the school for the meeting ready to see all of the others parents who must have been just as confused by this new system as we were. There were 2 other parents there. There must be at least 160 kids in 2nd and 1st grade at our school and 2 other parents cared enough to find out what the heck was going on. At this point I don't know what I'm more upset about. The fact that this big change is going on and I'm afraid my child will lose his motivation to excel or the fact that they can change all of this and the parents are too busy to care.

In the end last night the Principal explained that this is what the schools will be going forward with and they will even change it for the 3rd and 4th graders in the next few years. I do understand the system, now, and it does seem to be a more effective way for the teachers to see strengths and weaknesses. I think the only problem will be the communication to the parents because telling me my child is 'progressing' pretty much tells me nothing, right?

12 comments:

echoeve said...

I just want to say at this point I don't care anymore. It is what it is. They have made their choice and I don't have any controll over it. Whatever.
Bethany will be fine

echoeve said...

P.S.
I want to host a book club. which two are left?

Erin said...

We do a similar system here and it is so funny because I was just complaining to my mom about it yesterday. I too think it is hard to really tell how you child is doing.

I hate it too that public schools sometimes make you think that your thoughts and opinions don't matter, as if your not paying for it. You would never be treated that way in a private school. Oh, the joys of public education...

gigi said...

SEE, CHANGE isn't always so good! And if they can't even get parents involved in their children's schools how will we ever get things done in Washington!!!!!!!!!! Just sayin...

I can host the last book if you want me too. Just let me know which one! Love ya!

And by the way I love it when you vent, good job! Way to go and way to be there for your little ones.

Anonymous said...

I find this kind of thing so frustrating. It's hard when something isn't as effective as it could be, but there's nothing you can do about it - especially when it effects the kids...

I wanted to reply to your comments by email, but I can't find your email!

Elizabeth said...

Oh i'm so sorry. That just sounds crappy!!! Maybe I won't be moving back to GA!!!! LOL

Tara said...

I'm so not ready for all that school stuff. I'm enjoying the simple life right now...demanding, but simple. Good luck with all that!

Working Mum said...

I'm confused and I'm a teacher! 'P'? 'Progressing'? Of course every child should be progressing, but at what rate, at what stage? How long have they been progressing at that particular item? What is being done to help them?

Now you've got me venting!!

Sometimes schools forget how important parents are in their child's education, don't they?

scrappysue said...

i remember when we switched to the whole 'always', 'usually' and 'seldom'. it was so waffly, but i'm sure there's a method to their madness!

what i don't understand about your sheet, is that the "P" for progressing, doesn't seem to match the "P" for behaviour!

i mean, how can you be 'progressing' and at the SAME TIME not yet displaying satisfactory behaviour!!!

it's really just a way for the kids doing well to be glossed over and for the kids who aren't keeping up not be singled out as failing, because heaven forbid we should use THAT term!!!

Amanda said...

That's exactly right Sue. Next thing you know we will be taking the valedictorian out of the high schools because too many feelings were hurt. This whole thing has just gone way too far. I'm worried that the idea of 'no child left behind' is pulling the kids that are doing well back rather than pulling the ones that struggle foward. I could really go on and on about this.

The Clanton Gang said...

You can thank George and the "No Child Left Behind" crap for these report cards. :) Most other states have had this kind of system for years.

Let me add my two cents (backed by 8 years of teaching and being fed up with it.) This kind of report card is actually a better way of grading. It SHOULD give you a much better understanding of what your child should be learning in 1st/2nd/whatever. If they're making progress, then that's great! The old numerical grading system just isn't sufficient. So your child makes 100s on everything--does that mean she's mastered the spelling patterns on her weekly spelling tests or did she just memorize the list? Did he take a couple of good guesses on the multiplication quiz or has he actually grasped the concept of grouping and multiplication?

The bad thing is that most parents don't know the "language" of the report card and therefore aren't really up to speed on how to help their children. And "progressing" and "mastery" can be pretty subjective.

But overall, since you're a concerned parent, it doesn't matter how they "grade" your kids--they'll do well because they have you!!

Harmony said...

Our school's in Pa have not done this yet. But I can but we will. It seems that your state tries everything before us. I am not looking forward to this at all. I like to know where my kids stand. I do punish my kids for bad grades and yes a C is bad to me. Also if they do better one nine week to the next I like to know it to figure out what we can do or what we didnt do